The Impact of Immigration and Immigration Reform On the Wages of American Workers

Publish Date: 
5/26/10
Robert Shapiro and Jiwon Vellucci

Today, the New Politics Institute (NPI) is proud to release an economic report on the impact of immigration and comprehensive immigration reform on the wages of the American worker. The report written by NPI Fellow and Former Under Secretary of Commerce Dr. Robert J. Shapiro, presents an accurate portrait of America's immigrant population, dispels certain misconceptions about American Immigration and offers economic analysis regarding the impact of immigration, and proposed immigration reforms on wages and the economy. This report offers a much needed look at the intersection of America's economy and immigration system.

Below is a link to to the paper, after the executive summary there is an appendix which highlights some of the more pertinent information from the paper and Rob has blogged on the paper here.

Paper: The Impact of Immigration and Immigration Reform on the Wages of American Workers

Executive Summary

As the debate on comprehensive immigration reform has been rejoined, alarming amounts of misinformation are being presented as facts.  This report corrects some of this misinformation by reviewing the empirical evidence and evaluating the real economic effects of the recent waves of immigrants into the United States by analyzing the role of immigrants in our labor markets and economy.

This report presents an accurate portrait of our immigrant population, dispels misconceptions about undocumented immigrants, and reviews the evidence and analysis regarding the wage and other economic effects of both immigration and reforms to provide undocumented immigrants a path to legal status.

  • Immigration Population Demographics: More than one-third of recent immigrants come from Asia and Europe, while less than 57 percent come from Mexico and Latin America. A substantially larger share of immigrants than native-born Americans lack a high school diploma; but roughly equal shares of both groups -- between 28 percent and 30 percent - hold college or graduate degrees, and more than half of immigrants from Asia are college-educated or better.
  • Misconceptions about Undocumented Immigrants: Two-thirds of immigrants are naturalized citizens or legal permanent resident aliens, 4 percent have legal status as temporary migrants, and 30 percent are undocumented. While undocumented male immigrants are generally low-skilled, they also have the highest labor participation rates in the nation: Among men age 18 to 64 years, 94 percent of undocumented immigrants work or actively seek work, compared to 83 percent of native-born Americans, and 85 percent of immigrants with legal status.
  • Economic Analysis on the Impact of Immigration on Wages: A careful review shows that high levels of immigration have not slowed overall wage gains by average, native-born American workers. Most studies suggest that recent waves of new immigrants are associated with increases in the average wage of native-born Americans in the short-run and with even larger increases in the long term as capital investment rises to take account of the larger number of workers.
  • The Wage Impact of Reforms to Provide a Path to Legal Status for Undocumented Immigrants: The largest effects of such reforms would be felt by immigrants themselves: After the 1986 immigration reforms, wages rose by 6 percent to 15 percent for previously-undocumented male immigrants and by 21 percent for previously-undocumented female immigrants. Those reforms also increased wages of previously legal immigrants. Research also suggests that those reforms led to modest wage gains by native-born Americans.
  • Other Economic Effects of Immigration: Studies have found that immigrants are 30 percent more likely to start new businesses than native-born Americans; and even immigrants without high school diplomas, who account for 31 percent of all immigrants, comprise 27 percent of immigrant business owners. Various analyses of the fiscal effects of immigration have produced mixed results on the state and local levels; but studies show that immigrants have a net positive effect on the federal budget. Moreover, immigration reform would enhance these positive fiscal effects by indirectly raising the taxable incomes of immigrants and others.

Comments

Although Arizona recently

Although Arizona recently adopted a draconian anti immigration law, it wasn't based on economical reasons but more to avoid the violence and chaos related to substances smuggling over it's border. This has generated a lot of global visas complaints from people who were transiting the state unknowingly they were supposed to have their ID on them all the time. This kind of studies are here to show that misconceptions about immigrants, jobs and wages are not founded.

I agree

I have to say that you're absolutely right and that draconian anti immigration law is a junk and should never been implemented.

property management manteca ca | property management companies in sacramento

Solution needed, but what?

Obviously, drug trafficking over the border is a very serious problem, but is having everyone having ID cards really the best solution to this? all sports games

2

This topic has always been one of my favorite subjects to read about,
from game war 2
I have found your post to be very rousing and full of good information. I will check your other articles shortly.

motors guild

from tesla
I suggest this site to my friends so it could be useful & informative for them also. Great stuff.

Adoption

I must admit that the steps which the government uses are quite effective but can never stop the inflow of immigrants. hyip monitor hyip monitoring hyip monitoring

I agree

I personally agreeint to your insight. It was very informative and so true.

 

Web Design Perth | Perth Web Design

Surely, you are right with

Surely, you are right with this point. I think all consumers will not make their criteria become real for shopping since there are lots of choices.

____________________________

villa rental bali / bali

Misconceptions

Shapiro, presents an accurate portrait of America's immigrant population, dispels certain misconceptions about American Immigration and offers economic analysis regarding the impact of immigration. During my lsat immigration from my home country, friends told me finden Sie alle gängigen Hünnebeck Gerüste to solve my problems. 

Present very insightful.

Present very insightful. Never thought it was so simple after all. I had spent a great deal of my time looking for someone to explain clearly to this topic and you are the one who has ever made. Kudos to you! Keep it up ..click here

I am really impressed about

I am really impressed about this great post, As always I hope this article has been useful!

Iran Visa at Airport

our blog provided us with

our blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging.
writing a college essay

Appreciate

It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article http://www.linkbuilding-profi.de/7-backlink-checker-die-sie-kennen-sollten/.

I'd have to agree with you on

I'd have to agree with you on this. Which is not something I typically do! I enjoy reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment! openhaard

Obama Administration Sues to

Obama Administration Sues to Block Utah Enforcement Law President Obama's Justice Department filed suit November 22 to enjoin provisions of Utah's "Illegal Immigration Enforcement Act." evicting tenants

I wanted to thank you for

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

cell phone spy

spyI am glad to visit your

spyI am glad to visit your website.. This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality and it is very useful one and gives in depth information. thanks for this sharing this article.

cell phone spy software

Nice blog having nice

Nice blog having nice information. video submission service

Nice Blog...

I like all the events and programs details posted by this site.I daily check this site for getting more information about the news.bank exams    

Fellow

The report written by NPI Fellow and Former Under Secretary of Commerce Dr. Robert J. Shapiro, presents an accurate portrait of America's immigrant population, dispels certain misconceptions about American Immigration orthopedic idaho falls economic analysis regarding the impact of immigration, and proposed immigration reforms on wages and the economy.

Besides losing jobs, some

Besides losing jobs, some native workers end up reliant on public assistance. A 1996 study estimated that 1,880,000 American workers are displaced from their jobs every year by immigration and that the cost for providing welfare and assistance to these Americans was over $15 billion a year wireless internet

increases

the short-run and with even larger increases in the long term as capital investment rises to take account of the larger number of workers. Christian Web Design

brad pitt fight club leather jacket

Like this post good work.

brad pitt fight club leather jacket

Two-thirds

Two-thirds of immigrants are naturalized citizens or legal permanent resident aliens, 4 percent have legal status as temporary migrants, and 30 percent are undocumented.
ford repair huntington beach

The 2008 cycle saw a

The 2008 cycle saw a continuation of this new potent dynamic marquee hire– an anti-immigrant, anti-Hispanic national GOP, and a Democratic Party embracing, tentatively, the new demographic realities of the 21st century and one of its most visible battlegrounds – immigration reform. Once again the Hispanic electorate stayed with the Democrats and increased their share of the overall electorate. web design

Re

ow all those garments are so amazing and fabulous I don't come to your blog as often as I would like, but whenever I do I see some really amazing things keep up the good work! =)write my essay

Hope this would help to

Hope this would help to pretect US workers from the immigrated non-us workers.  medical aids in south africa

substantially

 A substantially larger share of immigrants than native-born Americans lack a high school diploma; but roughly equal shares of both groups -- between 28 percent and 30 percent - hold college or graduate degrees, and more than half of immigrants from Asia are college-educated or better. http://www.cashforless.de

More than one-third of recent

More than one-third of recent immigrants come from Asia and Europe, while less than 57 percent come from Mexico and Latin America. A substantially larger share of immigrants than native-born Americans lack a high school diploma; but roughly equal shares of both groups — between 28 percent and 30 percent – hold college or graduate degrees, and more than half of immigrants from Asia are college-educated or better pottery

 After the 1986 immigration

 After the 1986 immigration reforms, wages rose by 6 percent to 15 percent for previously-undocumented male immigrants and by 21 percent for previously-undocumented female immigrants. Hoist rings

and proposed immigration

and proposed immigration reforms on wages and the economy.

I believe that if there

I believe that if there hasn’t been an immigration reform is because someone is getting benefits of not having a reform. Many say that it’s important to have undoumented immigrants because business can exploid them and keep the economy competitive but we can learn from countries like Canada. Bad Credit Loans

karnevalskostüm

For a lot of occasions I’ve recently been searching for dependable as well as distinctive web page and this is definitely the best website exactly where I possibly could discover that. I appreciate the method you write your posts, incredibly skilled. I really could notice that you spent enough time and energy in composing your site as well as in discussing more information. I’ll take a note of your site as well as recommend it to my buddies.karnevalskostüm

Misconceptions about

Misconceptions about Undocumented Immigrants: Two-thirds of immigrants are naturalized citizens or legal permanent resident aliens, 4 percent have legal status as temporary migrants, and 30 percent are undocumented. While undocumented male immigrants are generally low-skilled, they also have the highest labor participation rates in the nation: Among men age 18 to 64 years, 94 percent of undocumented immigrants work or actively seek work, compared to 83 percent of native-born Americans, and 85 percent of immigrants with legal status. contractor mortgage

The American worker, families

The American worker, families and communities face a common problem today. It’s estimated between 13 and 20 million plus currently has settled and work in our nation unlawfully. The majorities are–ECONOMIC–and don’t pay local, state, Federal taxes and yet demand privileges meant for US citizens and legal residents, placing a massive yoke around government welfare and bleed this recessions sources of revenue. buy clomid

In addition to losing jobs,

In addition to losing jobs, some native workers become dependent on public assistance. A 1996 study estimated that 1,880,000 U.S. workers displaced from their jobs every year by immigration and that the cost of providing welfare and assistance to these Americans was more than $ 15 billion a year  viagra

Get it done Your self is so a

Get it done Your self is so a lot simpler whenever you can come across excellent reports similar to this one. z01sd | z012sd| z013sd | z014sd | z014sd

Really a good site

Reverse Osmosis of San Diego offers a variety of installed drinking water systems designed to remove contaminants from the water your family drinks. Installed drinking water systems can be tucked away under the kitchen counter or in the basement.

interval

A substantially larger share of immigrants than native-born Americans lack a high school diploma; but roughly equal shares of both groups SEO Agentur— between 28 percent and 30 percent – hold college or graduate degrees,

Re:The Impact of Immigration and Immigration Reform On the Wages

Yeah, but America is built by Imigrans, and sometime called brain drain it's mean all the best people come to America. Don't forget it!

Tile

I will get to know more new

I will get to know more new information. Even the website layouts and the designs impress me a lot. Private Label Rights

This is so amazing to use.

This is so amazing to use. The work that goes into this is so good. I have used it in the past and just love it keep up the good work. Austin Moving Companies

Re

Do you mind if I speak just a few of your articles as long as I give credit to the source and return to your blog?professional thesis writers

The strategies I personally

The strategies I personally attained in this specific blog is undoubtedly a new evidence that it is now easy to be trained and be notified of fresh information buy youtube views

t means you can add or remove

t means you can add or remove nodes and the database lives on. In a shared nothing architecture, if you lose a node, you lose the system. I'm sure Oracle appreciates EMC highlighting their advantage.I also desire to signal in your RSS feeds. airstream trailers

Consequently, that can happen

Consequently, that can happen that your site has low ranking. Do not understand a proper method to fix this problem?

Gull

It required a lot of time to

It required a lot of time to acquire this amazing and extraordinary website. It equally provided me with several facts that are great and important to everybody Best iphone apps

It proved to be Very helpful

It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article brindes promocionais

Tried to do the same as were

Tried to do the same as were told in the report but believe me it is not that easy to complete as many of my friends have also failed to do the same Firmahjelp